Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Enemy At the Gates/Kommissar scene

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #91
    I say more balanced, and you say that anything that deviates from Stalin's war-time propaganda line is "nazi-fanboy" or outright pro-Nazi.
    Do what you want, I'm just trying to tell you what would make a movie go over better outside your coutry. On the one hand you wail about how unknown the Russian end of the war is outside your country... and at the same time you want us to accept endless re-hashes of the same old tripe.
    We had movies like that too, made during the war.
    The war ended, we moved on.
    When will you guys move on and stop using that war for political purposes in the present?

    What do you mean by Stalin's war time propaganda ?


    "Orcs" is a straw-man, you invented it to make your opponents look bad, and I have never heard that term used by anyone in the west.

    You honestly have a problem with the cast?
    Do you have any idea who Bob Hoskins is?
    Or Jude Law?
    Ralph Fines?
    Rachel Weiss?
    Oh, Ron Pearlman must have caught your eye. He's a rough & ready type, and also one of my favorite actors going back a long way.

    If those people are not good enough for you, I don't know who possibly could be.
    A good review about the movie :

    http://www.battlefield.ru/en/hall-of...the-gates.html
    There are no Nazis in Ukraine. Idiots

    Comment


    • #92
      Originally posted by Emtos View Post
      ...no review there...
      Wisdom is personal

      Comment


      • #93
        Originally posted by Exorcist View Post
        I say more balanced, and you say that anything that deviates from Stalin's war-time propaganda line is "nazi-fanboy" or outright pro-Nazi.
        Please show me exactly what statements of facts have I ever brought up which are Stalin's propaganda that can be (were) refuted by any solid independent research in either Russia or the West. Otherwise I call your statements BS.

        Do what you want, I'm just trying to tell you what would make a movie go over better outside your coutry.
        I know very well what is going to be sold well outside the country. I have spoken to countless people from the "outside" and I've met Russians who lived abroad and saw what was told about Russia in the West. In Germany and Denmark (citing some recent examples) they show exclusively negative programs, and the Russian history from 1917 to 1991 is shown as one big Gulag horror without the slightest bright spot. Today's situation is shown just one tiny notch better. When the tourists come, they ask how it was like to live in Gulag until 1991 and whether the Americans saved the Russian Jews (all other ethnic groups of the SU were in some parallel reality in 1941-1945) from the Nazis.

        So this is what is going to sell well. The Russians who know what the war was like have a completely different picture of the events and they are not going to distort them to please the people who have been pumped with anti-Russian propaganda to the maximum for a century. Yes, I'm saying anti-Russian and not anti-Communist propaganda because of its abundant use of ethnic stereotypes.

        On the one hand you wail about how unknown the Russian end of the war is outside your country... and at the same time you want us to accept endless re-hashes of the same old tripe.
        Oh, I love a smug bigot enjoying his and his society's bigotry, using worls like "wailing". Martin Luther King wailed, and lots of Jews in the end of the 19th century wailed the same way until their kin ceased to be considered sub-human by the bigoted masses.

        We had movies like that too, made during the war.
        The war ended, we moved on.
        When will you guys move on and stop using that war for political purposes in the present?
        Please tell me, have you seen a single such movie? And have you seen any of recent movies? Or are you following the glorious Soviet tradition: "I haven't read Pasternak, but I condemn him"?


        Originally posted by ShAA View Post
        If they behaved exactly like it was in the "stereotypes", and it was documented, what's your problem?

        See above.
        Weaseling away? So I see you have a problem with the depiction of real historical facts in the favour of a more lenient approach to your beloved Wehrmacht

        What the hell are you talking about now?
        You know this perfectly well, but you can play dumb all you want.

        "Orcs" is a straw-man, you invented it to make your opponents look bad, and I have never heard that term used by anyone in the west.

        You honestly have a problem with the cast?
        Do you have any idea who Bob Hoskins is?
        Or Jude Law?
        Ralph Fines?
        Rachel Weiss?
        I don't care, really. The ones who don't look like monsters play roles carefully crafted to fit into the most bizarre Western stereotypes about Russia and the Eastern front. Ah, sorry, this is what you call an "accurate depiction" and what would sell well in the West.

        Nope, I sure don't.
        I wasn't there.
        How about you, eh?
        Ah, playing dumb again. Carry on with your dismissive attitude. But one thing I'm sure of, you won't dare to say the same "no biggie, we had our civil war, so let's forget about it and move on" about the Jews and their Holocaust which is perfectly comparable to what the Russian people went through in WW2.
        Last edited by ShAA; 15 Aug 11, 12:50.
        www.histours.ru

        Siege of Leningrad battlefield tour

        Comment


        • #94
          Originally posted by Karri View Post
          ...no review there...
          Here, I've salvaged the link. I agree with pretty much everything there.

          http://www.battlefield.ru/index.php?...id=108&lang=en
          www.histours.ru

          Siege of Leningrad battlefield tour

          Comment


          • #95
            Originally posted by Emtos View Post
            Reminds me :

            Soviet journalist Boris Strelnikov who worked in USA told this :
            -You know Miss Green that we lost 20 millions of people during the war ?
            -It's impossible ! In USA the life was difficult too. Gas was rationed and it was hard to buy chicken.
            I could find people where you live that have ignorant things to say about US history too, does that mean that everyone in your country has a distorted view of America and that all opinions from there need to be dismissed out of hand?

            BTW- what was the population of the USSR in 1940?
            "Why is the Rum gone?"

            -Captain Jack

            Comment


            • #96
              Originally posted by ShAA View Post
              Please show me exactly what statements of facts have I ever brought up which are Stalin's propaganda that can be (were) refuted by any solid independent research in either Russia or the West. Otherwise I call your statements BS.
              Now, if I read that right, you are saying that none of Stalin's wartime Propaganda can be refuted by the facts.
              Is that your final answer?

              Originally posted by ShAA View Post
              I know very well what is going to be sold well outside the country. I have spoken to countless people from the "outside" and I've met Russians who lived abroad and saw what was told about Russia in the West. In Germany and Denmark (citing some recent examples) they show exclusively negative programs, and the Russian history from 1917 to 1991 is shown as one big Gulag horror without the slightest bright spot. Today's situation is shown just one tiny notch better. When the tourists come, they ask how it was like to live in Gulag until 1991 and whether the Americans saved the Russian Jews (all other ethnic groups of the SU were in some parallel reality in 1941-1945) from the Nazis.
              You know, to hear you tell it, there is not a single communist sympathizer anywhere in the Europe, and that none of the people who come on your tours are sympathetic to Russia in any way.
              I know that ain't so.
              And maybe you would have better luck finding people with a more balanced view if you didn't blow people off who are looking for help, like that Italian Family you shrugged at last year.
              Yeah, you mentioned that, and sounded pretty smug about it.

              I have this mental image of you, wandering some Gov't land-fill looking for cigarettes , cursing outsiders and wearing your sunglasses on a cloudy day because the rest of us 'just don't ing get it, man'.


              Originally posted by ShAA View Post
              So this is what is going to sell well. The Russians who know what the war was like have a completely different picture of the events and they are not going to distort them to please the people who have been pumped with anti-Russian propaganda to the maximum for a century. Yes, I'm saying anti-Russian and not anti-Communist propaganda because of its abundant use of ethnic stereotypes.
              You find what you are looking for.
              And the ethnic side of it is something I don't see much of, probably because I am always focused on the political side of it.
              Not an excuse, I just blow off the racial side of things a lot. Bloodlines mean very little to me since I think that any child raised in a certain society will mirror that society... I.Q. and spirit having very little to do with DNA.

              Originally posted by ShAA View Post
              Oh, I love a smug bigot enjoying his and his society's bigotry, using worls like "wailing". Martin Luther King wailed, and lots of Jews in the end of the 19th century wailed the same way until their kin ceased to be considered sub-human by the bigoted masses.
              Stop using the same language and stick to the facts, and I will do the same. I might even start supplying some of the references that you constantly demand and never give in return.

              Originally posted by ShAA View Post
              Ah, playing dumb again. Carry on with your dismissive attitude. But one thing I'm sure of, you won't dare to say the same "no biggie, we had our civil war, so let's forget about it and move on" about the Jews and their Holocaust which is perfectly comparable to what the Russian people went through in WW2.
              Bolded- exactly what I say about the ACW, and the few lone freaks that don't think so in this country, I dismiss as whackos. 70 years have passed since the war you are talking about, which came only 80 years after the ACW.

              Playing dumb?
              Why? Because I admit that I was not in WW2, and therefore have no personal stake in it?

              You called me a Nazi Fanboy because I played the German side in a couple of wargames. I assume you are forgetting that I invited you to take part in a Wargame that I am still running ... perhaps playing Russia didn't sit right with you since it was still Czarist Russia in 1914.

              The Wehmacht interests me on purely technical grounds.
              You are not the first to make that mistake, someone once tried to recruit me into some gang, I forget if it was the nazis or the KKK... my answer was "If I wanted to get involved in a dead religion, I'll join up with the Druids".
              That was the last time I was in a really good fist-fight... oh well.
              "Why is the Rum gone?"

              -Captain Jack

              Comment


              • #97
                I could find people where you live that have ignorant things to say about US history too, does that mean that everyone in your country has a distorted view of America and that all opinions from there need to be dismissed out of hand?

                BTW- what was the population of the USSR in 1940?
                Batween 185 - 190 millions.

                Yes you can find many such people. But you have Internet, books, other forum users. But you still ask : Why you portray Germans like bad killers ?
                Because they were. It's a fact. US Civil War or Stalin propaganda had nothing to do with that. I don't see any reason why they must be presented like noble crusaders. I remember that in thread about attack in Norway, you had problems with some other users because they had said that it was done by the right wing. So I believe that you problem is not the portrayal of Germans but rather the portrayal of Reds as good people.
                There are no Nazis in Ukraine. Idiots

                Comment


                • #98
                  Originally posted by Exorcist View Post
                  Now, if I read that right, you are saying that none of Stalin's wartime Propaganda can be refuted by the facts.
                  Is that your final answer?
                  Eh? Let me break this down for you. You wrote that I repeated Stalin's propaganda. I invited you to point me out to this propaganda and bring up factual refutations of this propaganda from independent sources (US or British historians like Glantz, Armstrong and Overy would be just fine).

                  You know, to hear you tell it, there is not a single communist sympathizer anywhere in the Europe, and that none of the people who come on your tours are sympathetic to Russia in any way.
                  I know that ain't so.
                  Some small percentage of people is sympathetic, of course. However, it doesn't change the overall picture one bit. How big is the membership in the US Communist party?

                  And maybe you would have better luck finding people with a more balanced view if you didn't blow people off who are looking for help, like that Italian Family you shrugged at last year.
                  WHAT???

                  Yeah, you mentioned that, and sounded pretty smug about it.


                  Wait, now it looks like I'm remembering something. I think it was Stryker who spoke to the Italians. I don't speak Italian and don't remember consulting any Italians last year.

                  I have this mental image of you, wandering some Gov't land-fill looking for cigarettes , cursing outsiders and wearing your sunglasses on a cloudy day because the rest of us 'just don't ing get it, man'.
                  You should stop smoking pot right now, it's getting out of hand

                  You find what you are looking for.
                  And the ethnic side of it is something I don't see much of, probably because I am always focused on the political side of it.
                  Not an excuse, I just blow off the racial side of things a lot. Bloodlines mean very little to me since I think that any child raised in a certain society will mirror that society... I.Q. and spirit having very little to do with DNA.
                  This is why so many Russians had to change their names in order not to be castigated by the Free American Society and why kids were abused (still up to the 90s) at schools for being Russian.

                  Stop using the same language and stick to the facts, and I will do the same. I might even start supplying some of the references that you constantly demand and never give in return.
                  Like what?

                  Playing dumb?
                  Why? Because I admit that I was not in WW2, and therefore have no personal stake in it?
                  You don't need to have a personal stake to evaluate the moral aspects of it, as well as the value and significance of this war for the parties involved and how this was passed on to the future generations. I didn't mention the Holocaust as a rhetorical figure of speech - in terms of shaping the people's mentality, and historical memory, the war had a similar effect.

                  You called me a Nazi Fanboy because I played the German side in a couple of wargames. I assume you are forgetting that I invited you to take part in a Wargame that I am still running ... perhaps playing Russia didn't sit right with you since it was still Czarist Russia in 1914.

                  The Wehmacht interests me on purely technical grounds.
                  You are not the first to make that mistake, someone once tried to recruit me into some gang, I forget if it was the nazis or the KKK... my answer was "If I wanted to get involved in a dead religion, I'll join up with the Druids".
                  That was the last time I was in a really good fist-fight... oh well.
                  I've had my own observations of people who were interested in the Third Reich stuff (from reenactors to history buffs) and much more often than not you could find a swastika if your scratched the surface. I believe your words, it's just the past experience which made me doubt your political persuasions.
                  www.histours.ru

                  Siege of Leningrad battlefield tour

                  Comment


                  • #99
                    Originally posted by Emtos View Post
                    Batween 185 - 190 millions.

                    Yes you can find many such people. But you have Internet, books, other forum users. But you still ask : Why you portray Germans like bad killers ?
                    Because they were. It's a fact. US Civil War or Stalin propaganda had nothing to do with that. I don't see any reason why they must be presented like noble crusaders. I remember that in thread about attack in Norway, you had problems with some other users because they had said that it was done by the right wing. So I believe that you problem is not the portrayal of Germans but rather the portrayal of Reds as good people.
                    "noble crusaders"?!?
                    Wow, if that's what you think I'm selling, we have a major mis-communication here.
                    And that Norway thing was a reaction to the instant claim that it must be Right Wingers before there was any proof of that at all.... as was the case last January in Arizona. That shooter, in fact, was alter revealed to be Lefty.
                    And.... I guess you missed it when I used to lecture Heidi and others about Russian treatment of German civilians in 1944-45. I still think that the Germans got off lightly.
                    Yeah, I guess that just makes me bloodthirsty now, eh?

                    My basic problem with the Reds and the Nazis boils down to the same thing; normal people morphed into something else by very, very VERY bad ideas.
                    Period.

                    Fascism is dead and gone, totally dis-credited and never to rise again except in the fantasy-delusions of a tiny handful of fringe kooks.
                    Communism on the other hand, still has millions of advocates (have you seen how Divorced from reality Richtofen's posts can get on this subject?)
                    So, I don't treat communism with the same bemused detachment I do with other ghosts from history. Like the Bubonic Plague, it still has the potential to devastate the world.

                    Here endeth the lecture...
                    "Why is the Rum gone?"

                    -Captain Jack

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by ShAA View Post
                      You should stop smoking pot right now, it's getting out of hand
                      I wish.
                      The Biblical term would be "Pearls before swine" in my case. Pot and any other fun drug I ever tried never did anything but give me a headache, no fun at all.

                      Originally posted by ShAA View Post
                      I've had my own observations of people who were interested in the Third Reich stuff (from reenactors to history buffs) and much more often than not you could find a swastika if your scratched the surface. I believe your words, it's just the past experience which made me doubt your political persuasions.
                      A very limited means of communication, isn't this?

                      I do remember very clearly, from last Fall I think.... someone here that gives tours in St. Pete was talking about the mobs of tourists there on some big Parade day. A small group of Italians speaking English asked for something, and I thought it was you that just shrugged them off.
                      If I am wrong, I apologize. However, the incident confirmed in my mind that going to Russia to have a good time wasn't a great idea.
                      "Why is the Rum gone?"

                      -Captain Jack

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Exorcist View Post
                        "noble crusaders"?!?
                        Wow, if that's what you think I'm selling, we have a major mis-communication here.
                        And that Norway thing was a reaction to the instant claim that it must be Right Wingers before there was any proof of that at all.... as was the case last January in Arizona. That shooter, in fact, was alter revealed to be Lefty.
                        And.... I guess you missed it when I used to lecture Heidi and others about Russian treatment of German civilians in 1944-45. I still think that the Germans got off lightly.
                        Yeah, I guess that just makes me bloodthirsty now, eh?

                        My basic problem with the Reds and the Nazis boils down to the same thing; normal people morphed into something else by very, very VERY bad ideas.
                        Period.

                        Fascism is dead and gone, totally dis-credited and never to rise again except in the fantasy-delusions of a tiny handful of fringe kooks.
                        Communism on the other hand, still has millions of advocates (have you seen how Divorced from reality Richtofen's posts can get on this subject?)
                        So, I don't treat communism with the same bemused detachment I do with other ghosts from history. Like the Bubonic Plague, it still has the potential to devastate the world.

                        Here endeth the lecture...
                        Read my answer in Cold War section.
                        There are no Nazis in Ukraine. Idiots

                        Comment

                        Latest Topics

                        Collapse

                        Working...
                        X