The problem with most discussions in Alt history are the lak of context. Usually these discussions are set off with a simple "what if" question and everyone else is expected to bring knowledge to the conversation with no context.
This thread will sort that problem by having an OP with multiple scenarios, setting clear contexts. If anyhting is unclear about the scenario, please ask and I'll sort it out.
Scenario A.
Scenario B.
Scenario C.
Scenario D.
Scenario E.
Scenario F.
Scenario G.
Scenario H.
I think I've covered the main ones, refer to each scenario individually and explain why the Allies win/lose.
This thread will sort that problem by having an OP with multiple scenarios, setting clear contexts. If anyhting is unclear about the scenario, please ask and I'll sort it out.
Scenario A.
Normal Timeline till December
Japan does not attack America in the Pacific, Instead attacks Soviet Russia but does not attack British or Dutch interests in the East.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Japan does not attack America in the Pacific, Instead attacks Soviet Russia but does not attack British or Dutch interests in the East.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Normal Timeline till December
Japan does not attack America in the Pacific, Instead attacks British and Dutch interests in the East. America Does not get involved beyond further Embargoes on Japan(?). Japan Does not attack Soviet Russia.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Japan does not attack America in the Pacific, Instead attacks British and Dutch interests in the East. America Does not get involved beyond further Embargoes on Japan(?). Japan Does not attack Soviet Russia.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Scenario C.
Normal Timeline till December
Japan does not attack America in the Pacific, Instead attacks British and Dutch interests in the East. America Does not get involved beyond further Embargoes on Japan(?). Japan attacks Soviet Russia.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Japan does not attack America in the Pacific, Instead attacks British and Dutch interests in the East. America Does not get involved beyond further Embargoes on Japan(?). Japan attacks Soviet Russia.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Normal Timeline till December
Japan does not attack anyone other than the Chinese.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Japan does not attack anyone other than the Chinese.
America Supplies LL to Britain throughout the war.
Normal Timeline till 1939
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Does not attack anyone
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Does not attack anyone
Normal Timeline till 1939
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Attacks Soviet Russia
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Attacks Soviet Russia
Normal Timeline till 1939
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Attacks British and Dutch interests
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Attacks British and Dutch interests
Normal Timeline till 1939
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Attacks Soviet Russia and The British
America does not supply LL, but will trade with any nations with the funds and open ports to do so. Germany still invades Russia in 1940.
Japan Attacks Soviet Russia and The British
Comment